|
"Astroturf" campaign sparks
controversy
First came the outrage over companies submitting
information to bloggers that was repeated nearly verbatim in
blogs all across the Internet. Now, a similar phenomenon is
raising questions in the media about so-called grassroots
campaigns.
In his PBS blog, called MediaShift, journalist Mark Glaser
cites a practice that has become known as "Astroturf"-a fake
grassroots campaign which is, according to Glaser, "organized
by political professionals who want the appearance of a
groundswell of public opinion." Through this technique,
special-interest groups provide content for letters to the
editor, which are then e-mailed to various publications from
individuals who supposedly have composed the letters
themselves.
Glaser asserts that the liberal group MoveOn "got at least
six letters published that aped its talking points on fixing
Medicare," while the conservative Focus on the Family
organization "got dozens of letters to the editor published
using its letter generator that lets you pick and choose
pre-written paragraphs to create a Frankenstein-ian
letter."
Defending the practice after being singled out by the
Seattle Times, Focus on the Family Media
Director Gary Schneeberger wrote, "If it's unethical for
someone to sign his or her name to a letter largely written
and/or edited by someone who writes and/or edits for a living,
then where's the outrage over commentaries that appear on this
page under the name of a congressman or senator? Those pieces
aren't written by the congressman or senator him/herself but
by a staff member who helps compile the lawmaker's convictions
into a well-written whole..there is nothing fake about
that."
Glaser responds that "there is something very fake about
politicians using speech writers, but something even more fake
about letter writers, appearing to be just average citizens,
using word-for-word talking points from advocacy groups
without disclosing that information."
"As do most other public relations firms, Airfoil regularly
writes bylined articles on behalf of clients; but the
thoughts, opinions and recommendations are those of the
client, whom we generally interview extensively," said Airfoil
Account Director Leah Haran. "Grassroots campaigns, on the
other hand, only will be effective if the particular publics
involved express their interests in their own individual
voices. PR's role is to provide the facts, the arguments and
the call to action for individuals to draw on. Public
relations best fulfills its role when it can uncover and
communicate with a developing groundswell, supporting its
voices with persuasive information."
How do major media outlets come up with
ideas for all those stories that don't center on "breaking
news"-the features, analysis and profile articles that go
beyond and behind the hottest stories of the day? Corporations
sometimes would like to believe their news releases are on top
of the editors' desks and the top of their minds when they
look for these "enterprise" story ideas. But if the New
York Times is any indicator, these stories almost always
come from an idea put forward by a reporter or an editor,
rather than a release.
Times Public Editor Byron Calame, the readers'
representative for the paper, decided to examine where
enterprise stories are born. He looked at the front pages of
eight major sections of one edition of the Sunday Times
and found 23 enterprise articles (which excluded breaking news
and columns). He asked reporters to recount how the initial
idea originated for each piece. Of the 23 stories, 16 came
from ideas generated by reporters and five from editors. None
"came down from on high" from the 13 top editors on the paper.
Only two of the 23 started with ideas from PR practitioners,
Calame reports.
Managing Editor Jill Abramson said, "By far, the greatest
percentage of ideas comes from reporters. They bubble up."
Calame added, "While public relations professionals can play a
key role in the journalistic process, I was encouraged to find
that the ideas for only two articles came from them."
"The findings at the Times illustrate the importance
of consistent contact with reporters to offer information on
trends and developments as groundwork for story ideas,"
advised Airfoil Vice President Tracey Parry. "Public relations
professionals understand the value of establishing one-to-one
relationships with editors and reporters to help populate the
ideas the journalist develops with examples and insights from
clients and to help shape the journalist's perceptions of an
industry or marketplace. Simply sending out news releases is
not sufficient. The PR practitioner must become a true
resource for reporters to help them flesh out their ideas by
offering new environments, new agendas and new trends from
clients that may stimulate their thinking."
back to
top

Smartphones and lifestyles By Chris Yoon, Research Director, Airfoil
Public Relations
No one doubts that technology has changed our lifestyles,
but the pace of that change seems to be accelerating as we
enter the second half of 2006. For example, Podcasting-which
exploded in popularity immediately after its introduction-has
been around for a while now, but the latest trend is
videocasting. Web sites like YourTube enable everyone to
create their own video content and post it on the Web. In
effect, now anyone can produce a broadcast video program
accessible through computers instead of TV sets.
An even more significant trend is in the making, however:
the convergence of all sorts of communications and
entertainment in mobile devices, allowing people to do more
when they are on the road. With smartphones, individuals have
been able to stay in touch with the world through e-mail and
Internet browsing. Now, companies are providing video
downloads daily to mobile phone users, with sports and
entertainment highlights, music videos, movie trailers, news
and weather on their wireless phones. Windows Media Player 10
Mobile is just one application enabling mobile
entertainment.
In the latest expansion of mobility, consumers actually can
use their mobile phones to buy products they see in magazine
ads, TV spots or on billboard displays through "text to pay"
services, like PayPal Mobile. They can even use their phones
to transfer money to other people through simple text
messages.
Airfoil recently conducted research on the mobile market
and found:
- 77 percent of respondents carry their phone or other
phone-enabled mobile device on their person at all times
- 13 percent browse the Internet on their phone or mobile
device
- 4 percent make purchases on their phone or mobile
device
The mobile phone has become the link to lifestyles for
consumers, and we'll be eager to track the development of its
usage as capabilities expand rapidly.
During the 20th century, businesses targeted
their marketing and communications mainly to male audiences,
who were perceived to be the "breadwinners" and the source of
the disposable income for conspicuous consumption. Women were
viewed as a niche market more appropriate for marketing food,
home appliances and cosmetics.
The automotive industry ignored women for years, until the
emergence of the dual-income family meant two cars in every
driveway. Then automakers began assembling teams of women to
design their cars and SUVs. Technology gave women short shrift
as well, until the rise of online shopping and the capability
for social networking. Now women play a much more prominent
role on the Web. More recently, women have made their marks
among building-supply stores, freight carriers, highway crews
and a host of other once-macho vocations and venues.
Women have tremendous spending power, and increasingly they
are determined to maintain their economic status by managing
full careers at the same time they balance their home
life-financially, domestically and even structurally.
A much broader cross section of marketers now are targeting
these active women, who balance work and family life, through
traditional media and newer forms of communication. Airfoil
recently conducted research with a select group of working
moms to examine their media habits. Not surprisingly, we found
their favorite types of publications were food and
home-entertaining magazines, and their top priorities were
spending time with family, along with children's health and
safety. But local broadcast news and newspapers were very
important as well. Two thirds of them set aside time each day
for news and entertainment, despite their hard-charging
schedules.
Perhaps most revealing to some marketers may be the fact
that 80 percent of the working mothers in our study are on the
Internet daily. They have incorporated it into their office
and home life just as resolutely as the stereotypical male
executive has.
Three out of four of the women responding said they are in
charge of most household duties, and two thirds of them
involve significant others when making major purchases.
Clearly women have become a lead partner in the buying
decisions of today's families, and every marketer should be
communicating in ways that meet the needs and preferences of
the women taking charge of their families and their
careers.
To receive a copy of the research report's findings, please
contact Chris Yoon at yoon@airfoilpr.com.
back to top

Upstream CIO says technology PR firms
should show Big Oil how to work with the media
Upstream CIO magazine focuses
specifically on information technology advancements for the
oil and gas industry, and a recent letter from its editor
highlighted an interesting comparison between the media's
coverage of "Big Oil" and IT companies.
In the June issue, available
online at www.UpstreamCIO.com, Editor Jeanne M.
Perdue cites a quarterly study of news coverage relating to
the 100 top U.S. companies, conducted by media analyst
Delahaye, and ponders why technology giants are profiled so
much more positively than oil companies:
"Microsoft was the top company
to benefit from positive media coverage from January to March
of this year. IBM took third place, and Intel was ranked
fourth. HP's new line of digital products advanced the company
six rungs up the ladder to seventh place, its highest score
since its CEO turmoil in 2005.
"These technology companies
know how to get good ink!"
"But how did Big Oil fare in
the Index? Constant news coverage about consumer backlash
against huge profits and high gasoline prices pushed
ExxonMobil back two places to 21st place...
"Delahaye President Mark Weiner stated: '. The tech sector continues to be one of
the strongest and most stabile since the Index began in 2000.
Across 21 quarters of research and analysis, companies such as
Microsoft and IBM have consistently demonstrated their ability
to very effectively "manage" their reputations through the
media.'"
Perdue concludes in part with this plea:
"Here's an idea for the oil companies: Find out who the PR
agencies are for Microsoft, IBM and Intel and hire them to
replace your current agencies!"
Airfoil Vice President Eric Kushner, who oversees the
agency's work with Microsoft, advises, "Media coverage is the
frontline of corporate reputation. Rather than hunkering down
when times are bad or working to ward off news interviews,
every corporation should be proactive in communicating
effectively and openly through the media."
Just as the Web was about to pound the final nail through
old-fashioned subscriptions to newspapers and magazines,
subscriptions have come roaring back-Internet style- in a
format that few anticipated just a couple years ago. One of
the hottest Web trends these days is subscribing to RSS feeds
and podcasts, which allow computer users to have the specific
categories of news, information and entertainment they are
looking for delivered directly to their desktops, as soon as
they are "published."
Many newspapers have incorporated RSS feeds on their sites,
but few are podcasting yet. It's a different story for
conventional broadcast news and cable news networks, however.
While the audience for their on-air programs are evaporating,
broadcast-news organizations have taken the lead in offering
podcasts and RSS text for a now seemingly endless range of
topics and tastes, supplementing the video they make available
on their home pages.
ABC News appears to be out front on the Web with the
greatest variety of podcasts. It's one of the few
organizations sending out video podcasts-half a dozen
direct-to-your-computer videocasts titled World News Now; Good
Morning, America; Extreme Video; Ahead of the Curve; Buzz Cut;
and Fresh Trax. Its audio podcasts-some of them
bilingual-number no fewer than 43, including 17 from ABC
affiliates in New York, Houston, Chicago, Philadelphia and Los
Angeles. They range from news to entertainment, from "Medical
Minute" to "Desperate Housewives Minute," from money advice to
movie reviews. They're joined by 16 different RSS feeds.
CBS runs a dozen podcats-from "60 Minutes" and "Face the
Nation" to Frommer's Travel and Larry Magid's Tech
Report-along with 18 various RSS news feeds and 30 more just
devoted to sports. NBC and its MSNBC online site have come up
with a total of 13 podcasts-newscasts, "Meet the Press,"
"Hardball" and the like, plus a podcast where its White
House-beat correspondents answer listener mail. These are
supplemented by ten RSS feeds.
CNN is deeply in the game as well, but with somewhat fewer
RSS feeds and podcasts than the over-the-air nets, and the Fox
News homepage offers links to RSS feeds but no podcasts.
"The Internet has profoundly reshaped the traditional
broadcast news department," notes Airfoil Vice President Eric
Kushner. "With audio, video and scripting already in the can
for their television programs, broadcasters have found
podcasts and RSS feeds to be ideal vehicles to retrieve a
loyal news following. Moreover, while readers and listeners
could carry newspapers and radios anywhere, television was not
very transportable. Now TV news is making inroads not only to
the desktop but to the shirt pocket through podcasts that
broadcast stories on demand. These trends further extend the
reach of our clients' stories as we shape them for broadcast
outlets."
back to top

Technology companies seek Airfoil
marketing and research support
Airfoil is carrying out a comprehensive
public relations plan to support marketing for Fluency
Media, which recently joined the agency's roster. Fluency
helps companies link all of their marketing efforts-from
online marketing through sales and customer relationships-in
ways that optimize their marketing spends and drive revenue to
the bottom line. Airfoil is helping Fluency develop its brand
positioning and will work to establish the company as a
thought leader in its industry through media relations,
conference speaking engagements and direct-marketing
messages.
back to
top
Airfoil helps national eBay Live! conference connect
with media
When a record of nearly 15,000 eBay users from the United
States and around the world met in Las Vegas last month for
the eBay Live! conference, Airfoil was part of a collaborative
team that executed media relations and placed news stories
surrounding it. Airfoil worked in partnership with eBay and
PayPal PR, as well as other agency partners, to coordinate
media relations for the weeks leading up to the event, which
stimulated attendance. At the event itself, the Airfoil team
arranged interviews for eBay executives with national and
international journalists and broadcast media. The agency also
coordinated interviews with and escorted eBay spokesperson and
Dean of Education Jim "Griff" Griffith, who was in high demand
by the media in attendance.
Airfoil Vice President Tracey Parry said of the event,
"eBay recognizes this event as one of the most important
opportunities to connect with its community and the news
media. As a result, the eBay Live! community conference is one
of the company's most high-impact, and therefore most
important, annual initiatives."
back to
top
Practice
groups expand
Airfoil has added senior-level professionals and
coordination staff to its business-to-business and
automotive-and-manufacturing technology practices.
Emily Whitall is an account supervisor in the
automotive and industrial technology group, heading up
programs for Microsoft Automotive & Industrial Equipment,
Next Energy and other manufacturing-related accounts. Prior to
her position at Airfoil, Emily was an account manager with the
Campbell-Ewald advertising and marketing-communications
agency, where she provided public relations services for two
major automotive brands, along with consumer and
business-to-business marketing communications. Her career has
included positions with the Ohio House of Representatives, the
Michigan Association of Certified Public Accountants,
Corporate Express Distribution Services and Sandy Corporation.
Emily, who earned a bachelor's degree in political science
from Central Michigan University, is pursuing a master of
communications at Wayne State University.
Erica Stoddard has been appointed a senior account
executive in Airfoil's business-to-business group, where she
will work on such accounts as Microsoft and CareTech
Solutions. Erica joined Airfoil from GMAC Mortgage and
ditech.com. She served as media relations manager and
corporate spokesperson for these high-tech financial
organizations. Erica earned her bachelor's degree in
communications/public relations from Western Michigan
University, where she graduated cum laude.
Rebecca Wagner is an assistant account coordinator
in Airfoil's business-to-business group, supporting elements
of the Microsoft account and Airfoil's in-house marketing
efforts. A cum-laude graduate of John Carroll University with
a B.A. in communications, Rebecca interned at both Dix &
Eaton and Robert Falls & Co., public relations agencies in
Cleveland, Ohio.
Kirsten Smith is working on eBay, ePrize, American
Laser Centers, OnForce and Sikkens as an assistant account
coordinator in Airfoil's business-to-consumer practice.
Previously an intern with Marx Layne & Company and
Caponigro Public Relations, Kirsten managed public relations
for the Franklin Arts Council summer event, "Art on the
Green." She earned bachelor's degrees in advertising and
English from Oakland University, as well as a photographic
arts degree from Lansing Community College.
back to top |